Building space for business in Battersea

There’s understandably been a lot of concern about affordable housing in London – but less about affordable offices!  As London has grown businesses and employers are also finding it more difficult to find somewhere to call home, at a price they can afford – and with many of Battersea’s existing office and industrial spaces being replaced by new housing developments, if we’re not careful we’ll see local businesses struggle to carry on, and fewer job opportunities for people who don’t want to commute right across the city.

Wandsworth borough currently has one of the highest office occupancy rates in the UK – an impressive 97%!  There’s a major need for local business space – whether smart Grade-A offices, cheap and functional studios, flexible room for startups, or the semi-industrial space that keeps our local services running.

In this article we take a quick look at what is currently available, and what might happen in the next few years.

Big, glamorous offices

When you say ‘office space’, many people think of the glass towers in the city, complete with big glossy receptions and fast lifts.  In property developer terms these are ‘Grade A’  offices, i.e. smart / expensive spaces aimed at attracting big London headquarter offices. And several of these are being built in nine Elms – notably for Apple (who will be taking over 50,000 square metres in the power station itself in a year or so – that’s a big office, about the same as the Gerkhin skyscraper in the City) and the US Embassy itself (another 50,000 square metres). Penguin Books are already occupying 8,000 square metres by the embassy, and publisher Dorling Kindersley is taking over 4000 square metres right next to Penguin. There’s more of this to come with a further 20,000 square metre building being built between the US embassy and Vauxhall, and 70,000 or so square metres to be built in later phases of the power station project.  However a recent study on Employment Land and Premises identified that even after all these developments are built, Wandsworth will need to add another 30,000 – 65,000 square metres of office space by 2030.

IMG_20190828_175338679_HDRThese are important employers, and it’s good that Nine Elms is developing offices and jobs rather than just flats (not least because it’ll prevent it being a ghost town on weekdays) – but they aren’t the sort of spaces a small local business will be renting any time soon.

Outside Nine Elms, Wandsworth currently has 400,000 square metres of office floorspace of various grades of quality and price.  Some of this is used by the Council itself (albeit this has reduced quite a bit in recent years), and some by services like Royal Mail on Lavender Hill and the Wandsworth job centre. Some of the larger ‘accessible’ areas are the likes of Battersea Studios (which offers over 5,000 square metres of modern serviced flexible office space just off Queenstown Road).

A scattering of office spaces have been developed in new buildings along the riverside (and have been slower to let – as they’re not easy to get to – which is why policy now is to steer any larger new developments towards the town centres). Down the line, Clapham Junction is may well the biggest new cluster of office space outside Nine Elms – as it’s fabulously well connected, and redevelopment of Asda and / or the station sites could well see office space added.

Industrial spaces

Readers may be surprised that the Borough also has 1.5 million square metres of ‘industrial’ land.  Despite having one of Europe’s busiest concrete production facilities just off Queenstown Road, we’re not going to be seeing steelworks in Wandsworth any time soon – as the days of heavy industry in central London are long gone. About half of this is for actual ‘industrial’ use – including myriad plumbers, glaziers, builders, scaffolders, garages and others who look after our buildings, vehicles, gardens & streets – all of whom need somewhere nearby to call home. The rest accommodates the unglamorous but important services that keep things running – whether handling our waste, sorting the mail, processing deliveries, keeping things moving. Not to mention dozens of companies, from Chesneys (who repair and sell vintage fireplaces) to Caffe Nero (whose main roastery is just north of the Shaftesbury Estate – you can sometimes smell the beans!).IMG_20180922_163107340_HDRWe also have a brewery, a distillery, a commercial butcher, a winemaker, and even the company that maintains the gaslamps in central London – all within ten minutes of Lavender Hill. Honourable mention goes to the various local railway arches, and to the gaps between railways not suitable for housing (north of the Shaftesbury Estate), as a location for relatively affordable industrial space.

The draft London Plan now has Wandsworth down as one of the Boroughs that needs to provide new industrial space (whereas the previous aim was just to retain what we have).  There’s no new land, so this means consolidation, intensification, and co-location of uses where possible – as well as protecting ‘industrial’ employment areas, like Stewarts Lane. In the future, the most likely solution is to build upwards, and make existing industrial areas more dense – moving away from single storey warehouse buildings – while resisting temptation to build flats with token industrial use on the ground floor. 

Smaller offices

Battersea’s businesses are overwhelmingly small, and many employ under 10 people – covering every category from technology firms and event planners to nurseries, and property maintenance.  There are a fair few small offices, but they are popular and are constantly under pressure from developers wanting to convert them to flats and sell them off – which is an easy win for developers but damaging to the long term future of our businesses and our town centres.  This is why Wandsworth has put some restrictions on converting offices to flats along the western end of Lavender Hill.

IMG_6412There’s also lots of demand for offices for micro businesses (2-5 people), and the recent trend of some smaller shop fronts being used as offices for small businesses (for example at the eastern end of Lavender Hill) has been helpful for businesses, and reasonably compatible with the desire to keep an active and lively ground floor use for high street buildings.

Some tiny businesses also want space with the flexibility to move and grow – and don’t necessarily want to be tied in to a 15 year lease! This has fed in tot he rapid growth of flexible co-working space – the Battersea Studios (on Silverthorne Road) is maybe the biggest local example, but we also have many others including IdeaSpace on Lavender Hill, and the Scratch Hub co-working space on the lower level of Battersea Arts Centre. These can offer everything from a single desk (for the self employed who want somewhere other than home to work) to medium size offices on flexible terms.  These are very popular and bound to keep growing.

Affordable workshop & studio space

It’s not just about smart offices: more robust business space, where ‘messy’ creative businesses can operate, is also important.  The Battersea Business Centre on Lavender Hill is a good example of affordable workshop space that can accommodate caterers, workshops, artists and the like – an increasingly rare option in the area.  Fortunately it is being protected as a local employment space: the images below show the Employment Protection Areas along Lavender Hill.

What’s the council doing about it?

An important way the Council can steer the development of space for local businesses is via the Wandsworth Local Plan – an important document that sets the vision for future development in the Borough.  It matters, because any major new proposed developments (whether flats, offices or indeed anything of any size) will need to be broadly consistent with the plan. IMG_6354And the need for space for businesses is not lost on the Council.  We recently took part in a Council-led workshop with community groups, as part of their ongoing work to update the Plan (which your author has reported on in some detail on sister site the Clapham Junction Action Group).  It was an interesting discussion, that covered a surprising amount of ground, and we were encouraged by the thoughtful approach of several of the Council policy leads.  Everyone agreed we need local businesses and jobs, to avoid the borough being a dormitory suburb. 

With land at a premium, and flats always the lowest risk option for developers, the employment areas we have are always under pressure from developers, which means imaginative approaches are needed to keep our local businesses alive.  Local business space is rarely headline news – but hopefully this quick review helps illustrate why it matters!  We’d welcome your thoughts & ideas on the issue, and will keep you posted on any major developments as well as the the Local Plan.

Posted in Business, Planning, Retail | 4 Comments

Making Lavender Gardens more accessible

IMG_20200222_124651477A few photos of the works underway to create a new access path to Asda from the Dorothy Road – removing the steps.  We first reported on this small but helpful project back in January last year.  This will help accessibility – the steps were originally clad with distinctly slippery terracotta tiles, and were a headache for prams or frankly anyone who struggled with steps.  IMG_20200222_124641753The design has been refined since the original plans were announced – it was originally a direct line but we now have a gentle curve to better integrate with the park. It’s all being paid for by the Local Fund – that is, money paid by the firms building big new developments, towards local facilities.IMG_20200222_124709051The helpful new street light installed a couple of years ago on this previously dark stretch has mysteriously vanished during the works, but we’re assuming it’s getting slightly relocated now that the ground level has reduced.

Posted in Planning, Useful to know | Leave a comment

Is the second entrance for Queenstown Road station still on track?

There’s been a lot of new construction among the railway arches between Queenstown Road & Battersea Park stations. 290 flats, shops (including a soon-to-open small Sainsbury’s), offices, a new school…  and it’s now pretty much finished.  But one part of the plan has yet to appear: the ‘back entrance’ to Queenstown Road station. IMG_20191116_095953442_HDR

This was part of the project from the beginning. It was designed to improve transport to the new flats – as well as allowing more direct and pedestrian-friendly access between the two stations, and allowing people heading from (say) the Shaftesbury estate to ‘cut the corner’ by going through the foyer of Queenstown Road and get through to Battersea Park station slightly more directly. The entrance will be just to the left of the photo above – allowing a direct walk along what is billed as a “bustling new pedestrian high street” to Battersea Park station, whose distinctive arched windows are visible at the end of the street (the new Sainsbury’s will be at the base of that white tower, facing Battersea Park station).

queenstown rd

The back of Queenstown Road station – where the new entrance is planned

Taylor Wimpey developed what’s been marketed as the ‘Battersea Exchange’ district. They bought most of the land, and have laid out the new streets across the development, which go right up to the back wall of Queenstown Road station – which you can see on our photo to the right. We understand that Taylor Wimpey have generously put up most (maybe all) of the money to help it happen. Trouble is, they don’t own the station itself. And ultimately the timescales for adding a new station entrance are down to whoever actually owns the station building freehold – and they seem to be in no rush to get moving on the building works.

IMG_20200210_083328605Said works are pretty minor. That small wall in the photo has to go, the overgrown back yard gets paved over, a disabled lift goes in, and the door you can see on the left of the photo gets opened up.  The rather derelict outdoor privy visible at the right also goes, to tidy things up a bit.  Taylor Wimpey got permission to add a rear entrance in 2014 (planning application 2014/4687), and – after it expired without being used – applied for permission again last year (planning application 2019/1820). South Western Railway, who manage the station on a day to day basis, have been putting in other applications in the meantime- notably one to replace all the lights in the station with ore efficient LEDs (2019/5256) – which is a good idea, but which slightly worryingly seems to assume the back areas will remain unused and that no new entrance will be built.

qtr-station

The plans for the the new back entrance, seen from Patcham Terrace

IMG_6741

After half a couple of years of planning and three years of building works, Taylor Wimpey have sold all the flats and are now in the process of signing off on the completed Battersea Exchange development and handing it over to its residents and occupiers. 

It’s been a decent project – it has really opened up the previously inaccessible space, it’s worked hard to get the viaducts cleaned up and looking their best, and it has made ingenious use of a very difficult site with lots of different scraps of land and criss-crossed by viaducts. The project also involved complete rebuild of St Mary’s school.  It’s a very different kind of project to the generic suburban projects full of cul-de-sacs and ‘starter homes’ that the firm is maybe better known for, but it does continue a long run of central London regeneration projects by the firm, stretching right back to the 1970s regeneration of St Katherine’s Dock near Tower Bridge – which was probably the first of its kind.

IMG_6738

But we can’t help but wonder what has happened to the station element! Maybe whoever is ultimately expected to carry out these works is just taking their time. Maybe the money got lost or diverted along the way (though it’s hard for it to get diverted to something completely unrelated to the adjacent development). Maybe this has got tangled up in wider accessibility projects with slower timescales. Maybe everyone’s just forgotten about it… We hope the project hasn’t been abandoned, after all the preparatory work to create access between the back of the site and Battersea Park station.

While investigating the state of this project we’ve been in touch with those involved for their comment. South Western Railway pointed us towards Network Rail & Wandsworth.  Network Rail noted that they are supportive of proposals to make stations easier to access and integrated with neighbourhoods around them, that they are working closely with Taylor Wimpey Central London to review their design proposals for the public access route, and that they support the principle of it and a second entrance at Queenstown Road Station. We also spoke to Taylor Wimpey, who are investigating the status of this project and we’ll of course update this article if we receive a further update from them.  

Posted in Housing, Planning, Transport | 3 Comments

Last Orders for the Queens Arms?

IMG_20191116_102743117

Is the Queens Arms, which has been just off Queenstown Road since 1865, going to reopen?  It was closed in 2017 and architects Boon Brown won planning permission to redevelop it, creating five flats (four two-bed ones and a studio) by reorganising the interior, extending the upper floors, and adding a new storey on the roof.

There were some interesting disputes along the way. Conscious that many pubs in Wandsworth are now protected from conversion to other uses, the owners fought hard to be able to convert the premises to a shop, arguing that vintage clothing had regularly been sold without enforcement action after the pub was closed (and we did see a few rails, not that we ever spotted the premises in use or indeed signage or other signs of life)  – going as far as to submit detailed legal opinions to the planners, and leaflets and statements suggesting that it had traded as a shop ‘by appointment’ and that pop up clothing sales had happened there!  This didn’t, in the end, wash and the applications to change the use were withdrawn.

IMG_6716

The Queens Arms (at 139 St Philip Street) by night

The building is looking good – with the upper levels fully cleaned, new windows, and of course a new roof. The developers had to be careful: the pub is in the Park Town Conservation Area, and is locally listed as a ‘building of merit’.  The plans have preserved about 3,300 square feet of space for pub or restaurant use (most of the ground floor and basement). Both the kitchen and the bathrooms could potentially be relocated to the basement (which is larger than the ground floor), to make the most of the available above-ground space.

This space was offered to let with no ties (i.e. no link to any particular brewery) and ‘nil premium’ (which means there’s no up front payment to be made to the outgoing landlord for the value of the current trade and clientele, which seems reasonable as the pub has been closed for over two years). The expectation was for a 20-year lease, the rent rising every five years in line with open market rent or retail prices (limited to between 1% and 4% a year). Adverts for the pub also noted that offers may for the long leasehold or even the building freehold might be considered.

The adverts sought offers over £60,000 a year.  That’s maybe a rather ambitious asking price given that it’s a slightly tricky proposition as a pub (having lost its established trade thanks to getting rather run down towards the end, and then the extensive building work, coupled with no landlord accommodation any more, and not being on the busiest street).  We suspect it is more likely to end up as a restaurant – though again, that asking price is comparable with what ‘s asked for premises on far busier and more prominent sites on Lavender Hill. It was initially rumoured that a local operator with two other pubs in the area had signed up to take the premises on. But since then – silence. There’s no apparent sign of fitting-out works in the ground floor (as far as we are aware, it’s currently serving as a store room for leftover building materials from the flats above). There are no signs advertising the lease – however it seems that the pub is still available to let.

We’d love to be able to tell you what’s about to happen to the Queens Arms, or that we’ve heard a keen pub operator is about to get going and open it again. But this time we’ve drawn a blank! Do any readers have insight? Are you a budding landlord waiting to get going with big plans for the site? Please contact us

Posted in Food & drink, Planning | 1 Comment

Sainsbury’s closes for two weeks for refurbishment

IMG_20200209_164141524Regulars at the small Sainsbury’s at the eastern end of Lavender Hill will have noticed the tendency for their fridges to break down as soon as it gets hot in summer – leading to a day or two of hardly any chilled stock. It seems there’s finally work underway to install new refrigeration equipment – we saw the large chiller unit pictured below being unloaded on Sunday.

The store is closed for up to two weeks (until 22nd February, according to their signs), to allow for a refurbishment at the same time (the suspended ceiling had already been removed a few days before the store closed).  That’s a fairly extended closure (and quite a lot of lost trade) – more than would usually be needed for a refrigeration update – so there’s presumably also some other work going on to the building.  This unit last received a small upgrade just before the Tesco opposite opened.

Posted in Retail, Useful to know | 1 Comment

The Wandsworth Road Premier Inn is getting 13 more rooms

Premier 5The Premier Inn close to the Lavender Hill / Wandsworth Road junction is growing.  It currently has a little-advertised basement car park with 18 spaces for guests and staff (including two disabled spaces).  They’ve been underused for the last few years (and aren’t even featured on the hotel’s website), and in 2018 the hotel successfully applied for planning permission to close the car park and convert it to an additional 13 bedrooms – taking the total to 105 rooms, and work is now underway.

Work is now underway to remove the car park (pictured above), and infill the space.  It’s a relatively straightforward project as there are already a few rooms on the rest of the basement floor (so the lifts and stairs already serve that level), and the works are using the old car park access on Willard Street to minimise disruption to the hotel.

Premier Inn

The plan for the new rooms, (c) CHQ Architects

While  loss of car parking is always a tricky issue, it’s clear that the overwhelming majority of both staff and guests at the hotel use public transport, so the impact on neighbouring streets is likely to be minimal.  Back when the hotel was built it involved the sensitive restoration of the front section of the old Temperance Hall (which had become very derelict in the years after previous occupier Rileys closed), which was locally very popular, and by making it a smart hotel in an increasingly well connected location it has served the business well.  These new works – at the back of the basement level – will be hardly noticeable.

The original development of the hotel seemed a bit of a gamble, being quite far from any tube or railway station – however it has been a clear success, consistently being more or less full and receiving excellent reviews for its facilities (which are at the higher end of the standard for a Premier Inn) and its enthusiastic and helpful staff (indeed your writer has previously stayed there, and had nothing but praise for the team managing the hotel). We’ve also seen a steady flow of hotel guests visiting other local businesses (notably cafes).  We suspect Premier Inn will have no trouble at all filling 13 more rooms.

Posted in Business, Planning | 2 Comments

DIY shops on & near Lavender Hill: a quick guide…

file-49With B&Q in Wandsworth now demolished, and Homebase going soon, the ‘obvious’ DIY options have gone.  A question we’ve heard several times is what are the best local options?  There’s a little run of DIY shops and builders merchants on Lavender Hill – they all welcome custom, they don’t expect you to be an expert, and they can be surprisingly cheaper than Homebase and B&Q for a fair bit of the range. To help us all support our local independent traders, we’ve complied a guide.

IMG_20190518_104947551Lavender Hill DIY is small but a bit of an Aladdin’s cave spread over two compact floors; properly locally run (they have one other shop in Brixton).  Stocks smaller tools, paints, household hardware, a small selection of wood and electrical products, plumbing and a lot of general hardware.  Also does Dulux paint mixing.  147 Lavender Hill SW11.  Open Sundays.

Decor Express – A large store, focussed on paint and plumbing, with a huge painting and decorating range (pretty much any paint, varnish, or surface repair product available, as well as all the accessories & cleaning components you could possibly need) as well as a comprehensive in-house paint mixing service. Also stocks a wide range of tools, as well as plumbing components, screws, bolts and door furniture. There’s a smaller range of household electrics and cables, as well as wood and planks.  Helpful staff who are always happy to suggest what might be the best product for any particular situation.  Part of a mini chain of two (the other is in Richmond) and very much a locally run business. 44-48 Lavender Hill SW11; two thirds of the way along Lavender Hill, you can’t miss the big blue sign At the time of writing, open weekdays and until the early afternoon on Saturdays.

IMG_20190614_142220004Barker 8 – The absolute classic, an almost unique remaining example of a shop that still does more or less full counter service – so you ask and they go and find it from the back of the shop.  This may look like a very small shop from the outside but it’s on several levels and densely packed, so seems to stock virtually everything – including tools, general household goods, wood, electrics, paints, plumbing, ironmongery, cable, and a good deal more. The more obscure the item the more rummaging around it will take, and this is worth a look just for the experience.  Happy to advise on what might work in particular situations too.  They also have an in-house key cutting service.  8 Queenstown Road SW8 – the yellow shop just down from the Mini SainsburysClosed Sundays. Keep an eye out for the resident dog on weekdays!

LHP Lavender – this looks like a plumbers showroom, but actually sells a very wide range of plumbing related components to the general public, including pipe, brassware, plumbing-related tools, and also all the fixtures and fittings.  Larger items available to order – it’s not unusual to see big items being picked up here. As most of the customers are, of course, actual plumbers the prices are sensible prices – they can be quite a bit cheaper than the big chains.  It’s a counter service place, which means you can take something random along and say “have you got anything that will fit this”.  2 Queenstown Road SW8 Closed Sundays.

Asda also has a small range of DIY essentials (some paint, light bulbs, every day electrical items) on the upper level, as does the Kitchen Shoppe near the station end of Lavender Hill.  And despite the shop unit now being 50% smaller, long-established business Braggins are still definitely in business, selling carpets & flooring materials!

Slightly further afield, Leyland SDM on the Battersea Park Road have a similar(ish) range to Decor Express.  Screwfix further away at 208 York Road have an enormous range, some by ordering only but a fair bit of which is available to take away on the spot.  Topps Tiles are the nearest source of tiles, at Queenstown Circus (the roundabout half way along Queenstown Road).

For bigger items, Travis Perkins have a big branch about a mile from Lavender Hill. Welcoming to DIYers (just ask), if you want bricks, paving, electrics, garden tools, and wood, and especially if you want big and heavy things, they’re a decent option. They deliver daily to the area from the local store, so you should be able to get items dropped off at our door reliably and with a minimum of fuss. There’s a shop for their range of smaller items on site – the bigger stuff out in the yard is ‘pay in advance’. There is some car parking. Sign up for a (free) customer account and get a small discount.   37 Lombard Road SW11; there’s also a smaller branch specialising in kitchens on Battersea Park Road.

Wickes are a bit like an old fashioned version of B&Q or Homebase – a similar range but with more heavy duty materials and lacking the plants / blinds / cushions / more decorative elements. You’ll need to go all the way to the bottom end of Garratt Lane.  53 Plough Lane SW17.

Another version of this post covering a wider geographical area, is on the Clapham Junction Action Group website.

Posted in Business, Retail, Useful to know | Leave a comment

The local all-electric car hire service will soon disappear

bluecity2The BlueCity electric hire cars (which, despite their name, are red) will soon disappear from Battersea’s streets.  Despite some success with a ‘Hire-in-Gatwick, drop-off-in-London’ trial, the operators struggled to get sufficient use to make the £5-per-half-hour service profitable, and plan to close down for good next week.  BlueCity was a brave experiment, and it’s a shame to see them go.  We’ve previously reported on the local electric car charging options, and noted the tricky situation of the cars having to be stored in the ‘electric cars only’ spaces – which then meant that these publicly-funded spaces weren’t really available for other people wanting to charge electric cars.

IMG_20190107_145116054There were other problems.  The company found itself having to negotiate separately with every single London Borough to build, or gain access to, charging points, which proved quite challenging.  Wandsworth were quite proactive, but other boroughs seem not to have been interested. The cars had to be parked somewhere they could charge, and charging bays in popular spots tended to be full. And when the cars were fully charged, they could then block the spaces for days until someone else hired them. Unlike Zipcar, the BlueCity scheme never managed to get the same level of public attention, and maybe it never reached the scale & coverage where it was worth advertising widely.

Does this mean the end of electric hire cars? 

bluecity electricAlmost certainly not. The BlueCity service was always going to be a bit of an experiment at first, and may have been a bit ahead of its time. Unusually, the company made its own electric cars and batteries – designed to be robust and more suitable for public use, and at least in theory a lot simpler to maintain than standard cars with petrol engines. When we see chargers become far more widespread, and when it becomes easier to use fast charging points run by various different companies without needing a completely different account and system each time (so cars can be dropped off and picked up far more widely), this sort of service should be easier to develop.

The previous, difficult experiment in Paris 

BlueCity was based on a similar, earlier business that their parent company ran in Paris (called Autolib’), which was also closed down recently.  As in London, the main difficulty was making the business profitable, although with central government backing they got to critical mass more quickly there and had plenty of users.  They did, however, face a variety of uniquely ‘Parisian’ problems (NB: link in French) including cars getting endlessly broken in to and used as shelters and / or for drug taking, and a level of vandalism that we haven’t really seen in London (over 20 cars were set on fire!).  The shutdown in Paris was also more problematic – not least as the local authorities in Paris had often paid to install the charging points, but many were left with useless infrastructure after the scheme closed and the charging points stopped working overnight.  They had also installed dozens of small kiosks on the pavement to help signing up new customers, which were immediately redundant and quickly became dilapidated.

…but there’ll be no change for the SourceLondon charging points the cars used.

IMG_20191110_094958284

The SourceLondon charging points – which there are a few of near Lavender Hill – are also owned by the same parent company (French industrial giant Bollore). With a network of over 1000 charging points (far more than the initial number of BlueCity cars), it seems that these have found a reasonable level of use and will continue to run as normal – indeed, they may be easier to access if they’re not always occupied by the rental cars. There are a few local issues (for example, we’ve heard that the chargers in Westfield’s car parks are all out of order as the contract to run them wasn’t renewed) but by and large, these seem to be actively managed and get reasonable reviews.  Having spoken to the representatives of both companies, we understand that SourceLondon will not be affected by the end of BlueCity – it’ll be business as usual.

Posted in Transport | Leave a comment

Fresh new look for a tired old building on Lavender Hill

IMG_6413 (2)The scaffolding has come off 7 Lavender Hill – which used to be the home of CutPoint barbers over the ground floor and basement, and a 4-bed flat spread across the upper levels.  The property, close to the junction with Queenstown Road, was sold in 2017 for £915,000 (which apparently helped the owner move on to a happy retirement, after owning the building for 40 years!), and has since had a comprehensive makeover.  The building has gained an extra storey along the way and now houses (we understand) four flats, plus the shop on the ground floor.

The front façade has been comprehensively cleaned up, replacement windows have been installed, the brick pointing has been redone, and the stonework repaired and repainted (with the ornaments carefully picked out in gold) – it’s looking as good as when it was new! The contrast between the cleaned building and the long-empty Cedars pub next door is quite striking.  There’s still some work to do at the ground floor, but the overall result is already quite a change.  The work has been delivered by Balham-based APT Design and Build.

The Cedars next door is also slowly being internally refurbished, although it’s not yet clear whether the exterior will see as much attention.  It’s had a long fall from grace – in its final years it was the Ashtar bar, before they in turn moved to larger premises under railway arches in Vauxhall, since then it has variously been empty, squatted, and occupied by property guardians – while pigeons took over more and more of the exterior.  Fingers crossed the developers there will be inspired by what’s happened next door.

Posted in Environment, Planning | Leave a comment

The planning inspector agrees: advertising hoardings can’t avoid the planning process by pretending to be payphones

Max2 hugeSome good news.  Over the last few years, Wandsworth has seen a big increase in the number of payphones.  Which might seem strange, in the days of mobile phones – until you see these new ‘phone boxes’ and realise that they’re really just giant advertising boards, with a small payphone stuck somewhere on the side.  Planning rules conveniently allow companies to put new phone boxes in without needing permission, and a few advertising companies spotted an obvious loophole and started to put in ever larger adverts (proposals for Lavender Hill involved structures well over three metres high, and close to a metre and a half wide), coupled with typically-non-functional and never-likely-to-be-used phones.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with advertising – but with companies trying to put in clusters of vast illuminated hoardings (well over three metres high!) on all the most prominent parts of the town centre, cluttering narrow pavements, blocking views of listed buildings, and making it hard for turning motorists to see oncoming traffic, things were getting out of hand.  Some of the promoters took a distinctly aggressive approach – installing them despite refusals of permission, flooding Councils with dozens of applications for the same stretches of road, and taking all refusals to appeal.  Westminster at one stage received 300 applications for these ‘phone boxes’ in just two years!

Axonometric phone box viewWe’ve previously reported on this in some detail, and indeed fed in comments to the planning process on local applications (which were generally trying to argue that they did not need planning permission).  We recognised that not all operators are bad – indeed, BT and New World Payphones both took a sensible and responsible approach of working with the Council to identify suitable locations, and of removing several old phone boxes before they put any new ones in. BT’s InLink ones even offer free calls.

However a company called Maximus Networks Ltd wanted to put a huge advertsing hoarding on Lavender Hill, on the street corner by the Church of the Ascension – which would make it very dangerous to turn out from Stormont Road, and block the views of the church.  We (and others) were very concerned, and Wandsworth sensibly refused permission.  Maximus took this to appeal, and the good news is that the Government Planning Inspector has agreed with us and Wandsworth that the development was not exempt from needing planning permission.

new letterTo roughly summarise the inspector’s judgement, they concluded that these mega-payphones would clearly have a “dual purpose” – being a payphone but also deliberately providing a disproportionately large advertising hoarding, that did not seem to be necessary for the payphone’s day to day operation.   And because a recent High Court judgement (in a case involving Westminster) had concluded that the exemption from planning processes only applied to structures that were only for use as payphones (and not, say, snack vans that happened to also include a payphone…), the exemption from planning did not apply to these ‘dual purpose’ structures.

So it’s good news.  Our planners listened to us and others, considered the cases carefully, and took the right decision, and the inspector agreed that they had followed the right processes and made the right decision.  We may well see more adverts, and payphones, in the future – but they will need to go through the planning process.  Companies can’t just ignore local residents’ desires to make their streets more attractive, and install adverts wherever they like without getting permission.

Posted in Environment, Planning | Leave a comment